爱做面包的太阳花
Sunflower Bakery
← Back to Recipe Grid
❗Baking Science❗ Butter: Which State Works Best for Bread Making?⁉️
1 / 5
爱做面包的太阳花
爱做面包的太阳花
Jul 18, 2021
Buns

❗Baking Science❗ Butter: Which State Works Best for Bread Making?⁉️

❗干货❗黄油❗哪一种状态做面包最佳⁉️

Oven Temp
—
Bake Time
—
Batch Yield
1 loaves

🌼 Many factors determine whether a loaf of bread succeeds, and getting every detail right helps you bake a great loaf. Today's post focuses on butter.

🌼 First, let's look at the role butter plays in bread dough:

1. Butter enriches the bread's flavor and aroma.

2. Butter has great emulsifying properties, helping lock moisture inside the crumb.

3. Butter improves dough extensibility, allowing the finished loaf to reach much better volume and texture.

🌼 Next, here is a key baking concept:

‼️ Plasticity of Fat

✅ Plasticity is the property of a solid to deform under external force and hold that new shape. When plastic fat is incorporated into bread dough, it coats the gluten strands, boosting both extensibility and machinability. In the heat of the oven, it allows the dough to expand smoothly and hold its lofty structure without collapsing. Simply put, it helps the loaf spring high and stay tall.

✅ Fats exist in three states: solid, semi-solid (pliable), and liquid.

‼️‼️ Here is the most important takeaway:

✅ Semi-solid fat has the strongest plasticity.

❌ Liquid (melted) butter has almost completely lost its plasticity.

❌ Cold, hard solid butter is too stiff to incorporate evenly into the dough.

🔑 Conclusion:

‼️ Always use softened, pliable room-temperature butter when making bread! ‼️

💡 Baker's Q&A & Troubleshooting (14)

Distilled from Author's Notes
Q:In the summer, if I use softened butter, what if my final dough temperature comes out of the mixer too high?
A:As long as your major ingredients (like flour and liquids) come straight from the fridge or freezer, 20 to 30 grams of room-temperature butter has very little impact on the total dough temperature. On the flip side, if you throw in hard, cold butter, the mixer has to work much longer to incorporate it, and the extra friction heat from prolonged mixing raises the dough temperature far more than softened butter would.
Q:I melted my butter over hot water before seeing this post! What should I do?
A:Let it cool down in the fridge for a little while until it firms back up into a semi-solid paste.
Q:How long does it take to soften butter at room temperature? How far in advance should I take it out, and is it ready when my finger leaves an indentation?
A:In summer it softens very quickly; in winter it takes longer. Cutting the butter into small cubes right after taking it out speeds things up. Once it yields easily when pressed with a finger, it is ready to use.
Q:Do all three states taste the same in the finished bread?
A:Yes, the flavor itself is pretty much the same, though the texture and volume will differ.
Q:I overheated the butter packet that came with my steak and it separated like this. Why?
A:Butter has a very low melting point, so overheating quickly melts and separates the milk solids from the butterfat.
Q:Great post! Do you use cultured butter or regular sweet cream butter for bread?
A:Thank you! I use both regularly.
Q:How do you soften butter in the winter when the house is cold?
A:Take it out of the fridge early, cut it into small cubes, and set it in a warm spot in the kitchen, like near the stove or on a sunny windowsill.
Q:室温软化黄油要多久呀 也就是请问提前多久拿出来 或者请问是能按出坑就是说明可以用了吗
A:夏天挺快的,冬天会慢一些,拿出来后切小块,会更快一些。手指摁一下是软的就可以了
Q:The butter that came with the steak became like this when overheated.
A:The melting point of butter is very low.
Q:The butter melted with hot water, what to do Saw it too late
A:Can be left for a while to slightly change into a semi-solid state
Q:三种味道是一样的吗
A:I think the taste is similar.
Q:Excellent! Is the butter used for making bread fermented or regular butter?
A:Thank you, sisters I will use them all
Q:Use softer butter in summer, what to do if the dough temperature is high when it comes out of the mixer
A:In most cases where ingredients like flour and liquids are taken out of the refrigerator for use, the temperature of the entire dough is not significantly affected by 20 to 30 grams of room-temperature butter. Imagine if the butter were hard; then more stirring would be needed to incorporate it into the dough, and the heat generated by this stirring would raise the dough's temperature more than room-temperature butter would. This is great 👍
Q:How do you handle it in winter?
A:提早冰箱取出,切小块,放到家里温暖的角落,比如炉头附近,有阳光的窗口

💬 Website Comments (0)

Curated reader Q&As and troubleshooting notes are listed above.

❤️ 207⭐ 188💡 14 Q&As
Permalink ↗