Question 1

Is the hydration on the low side? My mixed sponge felt as firm as steamed bun dough.

Accepted Answer

Do you mean at the sponge stage? Yes, the sponge itself is intentionally quite firm, and different flours absorb liquid differently. Once you add the main dough ingredients (sugar, condensed milk, cream, and butter) the next day, the dough softens right up into a supple, non-sticky toast dough. When shaping, dust the counter lightly with flour if needed, roll into an oval, flip it over, fold both sides toward the center, and roll it up. And if you see tiny white flecks, that is just unhydrated flour from the sponge if it wasn't kneaded evenly the night before.

Question 2

If I want to substitute yogurt (like thick Greek or drinking yogurt) for the milk in this recipe, how many grams should I use?

Accepted Answer

Regular yogurt is around 80% water, while milk is about 88% water. Since 175g of milk provides roughly 154g of water (175 x 0.88), you would need about 190g of yogurt (190 x 0.80 = 152g) to get the same hydration. To be safe, always hold back 15g to 20g and add it gradually as the dough mixes.

Question 3

In Step 3, after rolling out and placing the coils in the pan, does it only proof that one time?

Accepted Answer

Yes! Because the sponge already fermented overnight, you shape it right after mixing the main dough and give it just one final proof in the pan. And for mixing the sponge the night before, you can easily do it by hand: stir into shaggy flakes with chopsticks, knead briefly into a ball, rest covered for 15 minutes, then knead a few more times until smooth.

Question 4

Mine failed! When dividing the dough there were lots of gas bubbles. I don't know if I overmixed it in the warm weather, and after proofing to 80% full it didn't rise at all in the oven or shred, leaving coarse holes like a steamed cake.

Accepted Answer

With warm weather, it sounds like the dough over-proofed or got too warm during mixing. Over-fermented dough loses its gluten structure and oven spring, resulting in a coarse, cake-like crumb.

Question 5

Does the final proof on the second day require humidity?

Accepted Answer

Yes. After shaping and panning, place the loaf in a warm, humid environment. I proof mine inside the turned-off oven with a bowl of hot water to provide warmth and steam, swapping out the hot water twice during proofing.

Question 6

Can I replace the heavy whipping cream with regular milk?

Accepted Answer

Yes, you can. Just don't swap it 1:1; use slightly less milk (around 6g to 7g) because milk has a higher water content than heavy cream.

Question 7

Is there any difference in texture between the 100% sponge method and the 70% sponge method?

Accepted Answer

Honestly, I can't taste a difference between the two, so I prefer 100% sponge simply because weighing all the flour at once is more convenient.

Question 8

Just finished baking this and it turned out amazing! It rose so tall toward the top heating element that I tented it with foil right away. It shreds beautifully and is super soft and delicious. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe!

Accepted Answer

That makes me so happy, even happier than when I bake a great loaf myself!

Question 9

How can I tweak the formula to make the crumb even moister and softer?

Accepted Answer

Check out my Matcha Hokkaido Milk Pullman Loaf post, which has higher cream and hydration for an ultra-moist texture.

Question 10

Mine failed! When dividing the dough there were lots of gas bubbles. I don't know if I overmixed it in the warm weather, and after proofing to 80% full it didn't rise at all in the oven or shred, leaving coarse holes like a steamed cake.

Accepted Answer

With warm weather, it sounds like the dough over-proofed or got too warm during mixing. Over-fermented dough loses its gluten structure and oven spring, resulting in a coarse, cake-like crumb.

Question 11

If I want to substitute yogurt (like thick Greek or drinking yogurt) for the milk in this recipe, how many grams should I use?

Accepted Answer

Regular yogurt is around 80% water, while milk is about 88% water. Since 175g of milk provides roughly 154g of water (175 x 0.88), you would need about 190g of yogurt (190 x 0.80 = 152g) to get the same hydration. To be safe, always hold back 15g to 20g and add it gradually as the dough mixes.

Question 12

Just finished baking this and it turned out amazing! It rose so tall toward the top heating element that I tented it with foil right away. It shreds beautifully and is super soft and delicious. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe!

Accepted Answer

That makes me so happy, even happier than when I bake a great loaf myself!

Question 13

If I want to bake this with the lid on, do I need to change the temperature and bake time?

Accepted Answer

In my built-in oven, a lidded Pullman pan needs 10°C higher heat and 5 extra minutes. In my smaller countertop oven, which runs much hotter, I keep the same temperature and just add about 2 minutes. Test and adjust based on how your own oven runs.

Question 14

In Step 3, after rolling out and placing the coils in the pan, does it only proof that one time?

Accepted Answer

Yes! Because the sponge already fermented overnight, you shape it right after mixing the main dough and give it just one final proof in the pan. And for mixing the sponge the night before, you can easily do it by hand: stir into shaggy flakes with chopsticks, knead briefly into a ball, rest covered for 15 minutes, then knead a few more times until smooth.

Question 15

I have every ingredient at home except heavy whipping cream. What can I substitute for it?

Accepted Answer

Use about 6g of milk instead, adding it gradually as needed.

Question 16

Is the hydration on the low side? My mixed sponge felt as firm as steamed bun dough.

Accepted Answer

Do you mean at the sponge stage? Yes, the sponge itself is intentionally quite firm, and different flours absorb liquid differently. Once you add the main dough ingredients (sugar, condensed milk, cream, and butter) the next day, the dough softens right up into a supple, non-sticky toast dough. When shaping, dust the counter lightly with flour if needed, roll into an oval, flip it over, fold both sides toward the center, and roll it up. And if you see tiny white flecks, that is just unhydrated flour from the sponge if it wasn't kneaded evenly the night before.

Question 17

Does the final proof on the second day require humidity?

Accepted Answer

Yes. After shaping and panning, place the loaf in a warm, humid environment. I proof mine inside the turned-off oven with a bowl of hot water to provide warmth and steam, swapping out the hot water twice during proofing.

Question 18

After mixing the sponge with the main dough ingredients, do I shape it directly for a single proof?

Accepted Answer

Yes, shape it right after mixing and give it just one final proof in the pan.

Question 19

How do you get that feathery pull-apart shred?

Accepted Answer

Chilling the sponge overnight makes it very easy to mix to a full windowpane, and strong gluten development is what creates that feathery shred. The cold sponge also keeps the dough temperature low during mixing so it doesn't ferment prematurely in the bowl, which prevents coarse holes.

Question 20

Can I leave out both the heavy whipping cream and sweetened condensed milk? Do I need to replace them with anything?

Accepted Answer

You can omit them: the condensed milk adds milky sweetness and the cream softens the crumb. Check the dough consistency as you mix; if it feels fine, you don't need to add anything, or if it feels slightly dry, add about 10g of water or milk gradually.

Question 21

Is there any difference in texture between the 100% sponge method and the 70% sponge method?

Accepted Answer

Honestly, I can't taste a difference between the two, so I prefer 100% sponge simply because weighing all the flour at once is more convenient.

❤️Pull-Apart Matcha Pullman Loaf❤️ 100% Sponge Method❤️

🍞 Formula & Measurements

💡 Baker's Q&A & Troubleshooting (21)

💬 Website Comments (0)